Saturday, February 2, 2008

Sean Casey, the bench and Tony Gwynn Jr.

So originally when I read that Sean Casey was going to the Red Sox this year, I wasn't really upset or concerned in anyway because Casey plays first base.  But I did get upset when I found out that Casey will only be receiving $800,000 this year.  Wow, that's it?!  Listen, I know that the Brewers don't need a first baseman, but Casey signed to play the third string.  How many lefty bats does this Brewer team have.

I'm not saying we should have signed him, I'm just saying that paying a guy less than a mil to sit on your bench and bat .280 instead of .220 like Craig Counsell, is more worth the cash.  Counsell is making $2.8 mil this year to drag this team down with solid defense and lack luster plate appearances.  It's one thing to give a utility player his money, but it's another if that player is one of the two lefties on your bench. 

 I think the bench of this team is its weakest point.  While guys like Gross and Gwynn will be pretty decent players, there is zero pop on the pine, ESPECIALLY for an NL team.  Situational hitting is going to be non-existent unless Tony Gwynn is called out there to bunt or Counsell is asked to take one to the opposite field to get a run in, and that's provided they give Gwynn the spot he deserves.  

I'm a firm believer in Tony Gwynn Jr.  I think he brings a different kind of element to this team.  He's a great clubhouse guy, who with Prince and Rickie make you want to watch baseball and see what stupid stuff they'll do together.  On top of that, you get a guy who will do anything to get on base, whether it's bunt, slash or take one to the mouth.  He's going to give you just as many HRs as Jason Kendall, but he's going to give you that lefty option off the bench and more importantly, a pinch runner for guys like Prince or JJ when things go awry in the later innings and you need that last run.  Those are things that get an NL team over the hump.

2 comments:

steve said...

I second your motion for Tony Gwynn JR. Unfortunately, I think we are totally in the minority. Most Brewer fans and baseball ones in general for that matter...call Gwynn very over-rated. Oh well, that's no reasons to abandon our own instincts. I would have preferred Gwynn being handed Center field this year or left field before the switcharoo.

The Brewers have complete confidence in his defense, so what are they risking by inserting him in the 8th spot and sending his glove and intelligent speed out to play defense?

I hope I am wrong and Cameron explodes at Miller Park doubling his output from previous years playing at Pet County Field....as in spacious like an entire county!

I'm concerned a bit too about Prince being our ONLY lefty bat...That seems significant...I'm in favour of Counsell and Gross being on the team, but their role is not as a proven-legit threat from the left side of the plate.

Brewer Nation discusses this today...available free agents. Is there anyone we could get for a Casey like price?

akittell said...

While there's a significant amount of free agents out there, it appears that none of them would fit this roster right now. Some people think we should have took a run at Corey Patterson, but the guy is over-rated, no power, no on-base, just speed and defense, which this team has plenty of. Lofton would have been a perfect platoon player, but that doesn't fit here any more either. The best thing for us is maybe a lefty reliever, but there aren't any decent ones out there.